Every tutor has heard it, usually as a joke: those who can't do, teach.
There's something in it. But the part it gets wrong is the part that matters most to anyone choosing a tutor.
Where the line comes from
The popular version paraphrases George Bernard Shaw. In Maxims for Revolutionists, published with his 1903 play Man and Superman, under the heading "Education", he wrote: "He who can, does. He who cannot, teaches."
The idea is simple. The real skill is doing the thing. Teaching is what's left for people who couldn't.
What it gets right about tutoring
Shaw was right that doing and teaching are different things, and tutoring makes that easy to see. It has a low barrier to entry: a good grade in the subject and a few students are enough to start. A common way to run lessons, especially for newer or part-time tutors, is as a consultation: the student brings questions, the tutor answers them.
That isn't wrong. It's what one-to-one tutoring is set up to do, and some students need exactly that. A confident student with a specific gap, or one who just wants someone to check their thinking before a test, can be well served by a tutor who answers questions clearly.
What it misses: the questions a student can't ask
A consultation has one limit built in. A student can only ask about the gaps they know they have.
The gaps that cost the most marks are usually the ones they can't see: writing "cost" when they mean "price" (I've written about that one in particular), drawing a diagram without explaining it, or ending a 15-mark essay with "it depends" and no judgement. The student doesn't ask about these because, to them, there's nothing to ask.
A tutor's job is to know what the student doesn't know, even when the student doesn't know they don't know.
I remember that feeling from the student's side. Before Economics clicked for me, the worst part wasn't finding it hard. It was not knowing what I didn't know.
This is also where Shaw's line falls apart. In 1986 the education researcher Lee Shulman answered it directly: "We reject Mr. Shaw and his calumny." His rewrite was "Those who can, do. Those who understand, teach." Teaching, he argued, needs a kind of knowledge that goes beyond knowing the subject: the "ways of representing and formulating the subject that make it comprehensible to others", including knowing which mistakes students make and why.
I see a version of this on a softball field. Players who can describe their swing in detail still miss the ball, and the coach who helps most is the one who can see what they're doing wrong when they can't. Knowing a thing, doing it, and helping someone else do it are three different skills.
Where full-time teaching shows
Spotting the gaps a student can't see comes from seeing the same mistakes across many students. Full-time teaching gives a tutor more of that exposure and more hours to act on it, which is why I think full-time tutors are more likely, and better placed, to turn it into materials. Plenty of part-time tutors do this well too. Answering questions shows you can do Economics. Building resources around the mistakes you keep seeing shows you understand how students learn it.
These are the kinds of resources I mean, with one I've built for my students at KS Academia Prep for each:
- Personalised resources: an IB exam calendar that builds a timetable for each student's own subjects.
- Summary notes: such as the basic economic problem, explained for IGCSE.
- Model essays: a full 8-mark model answer on fiscal policy and HDI, written point by point.
- Lesson plans: the course plan behind the IGCSE Economics classes I teach.
- Handouts: the diagrams for each syllabus, as downloadable guides for IGCSE Economics and IB Economics.
- Blog articles: longer pieces such as a question-by-question breakdown of IGCSE past papers.
Resources like these rarely come out of answering one student's questions. They come from noticing that the same gap appears in student after student, and building something so the next student doesn't fall into it.
What to ask instead
"Could this tutor do it?" is the wrong question, or at least an incomplete one. Better questions for a parent:
- Can you show my child how? Bring a real piece of work to a trial lesson and see how specific the feedback is.
- What will my child find that they didn't know to ask about? A good answer names the common gaps for that syllabus without being prompted.
- What materials come with the lessons, and who made them?
I've written more about what changes when teaching is someone's whole job and about how evaluation is marked across IGCSE, IB and H2. At KS Academia Prep, students' results and reviews are published in their own words, and if you'd like to see how I teach, the centre offers paid trial lessons for IGCSE and IB Economics.
Shaw was right that teaching isn't the same as doing. He was wrong about which one is the lesser skill.
Sources
- George Bernard Shaw, Maxims for Revolutionists (published with Man and Superman, 1903), "Education" (Project Gutenberg)
- Lee S. Shulman (1986), "Those Who Understand: Knowledge Growth in Teaching", Educational Researcher, 15(2), 4 to 14
Quotations from Shaw and Shulman are from the sources listed. The view of tutoring and the resources described are my own.