I teach three Economics syllabuses in the same week: IGCSE and IB at KS Academia Prep, and H2 at Higher Nucleus. Students often assume evaluation means something different in each. The wording differs, but the skill underneath is the same, so I teach it the same way.
Here is what each syllabus actually asks for, in its own published words.
Where the evaluation marks are
| IGCSE 0455 (2027 to 2029) | IB (SL and HL) | H2 9570 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Longest written question | Paper 2 part (d), "Discuss whether or not...", 8 marks | Paper 1 part (b), 15 marks; Paper 2 part (g), 15 marks | Paper 2 essays, 25 marks each: part (a) 10, part (b) 15 |
| Paper | Paper 2: 2 hours, 80 marks | Paper 1: 1 hour 15 minutes; Paper 2: 1 hour 45 minutes | Paper 2: 2 hours 30 minutes, three essays from six |
| Evaluation objective | AO3 Evaluation, 15% of Paper 2 | AO3 Synthesis and evaluation, in part (b) and part (g) only | AO4 Evaluation |
What each one asks for
IGCSE. The top level of Cambridge's mark scheme for the 8-mark question is "a reasoned discussion which accurately considers two sides of an economic argument". One side may have more depth than the other, but both must be "considered and developed". Interestingly, "Evaluate" isn't one of the syllabus command words at all. The evaluation lives inside "Discuss".
IB. The 13 to 15 band for the 15-mark questions asks for "effective and balanced synthesis or evaluation", and in Paper 1, "a relevant real-world example(s)... fully developed to support the argument". In Paper 2 part (g), the extract data has to be "used to formulate a reasoned argument".
H2. SEAB's AO4 reads: "Evaluate critically contemporary issues, perspectives and policy choices", "Recognise unstated assumptions and evaluate their relevance", and "Synthesise economic arguments to arrive at well-reasoned judgements and decisions". SEAB doesn't publish level descriptors for 9570, so the syllabus wording is the best guide to what is rewarded.
The pattern: IGCSE asks for two developed sides. IB adds a judgement grounded in a real example. H2 adds a challenge to the assumptions behind the argument. Each level keeps everything from the one before.
One method for all three
The evaluation step in my classes uses four questions. They come from what I call Contextualised Evaluation, and every student gets the same four regardless of syllabus:
- Context. Does this work in this economy, with these features? A small, open economy and a large, closed one respond differently to the same policy.
- Time frame. What happens in the short run, and does it still hold in the long run?
- Magnitude. How big is the effect? Usually this comes down to an elasticity or the size of the change.
- Effectiveness. Does the policy achieve its aim, at what cost, and is there a better alternative?
Then the answer has to decide. "It depends" is only the start of a judgement; the finish is saying what it depends on most, and why.
How far to take it at each level
- IGCSE: develop both sides properly, then end with one sentence on what the outcome depends on. That costs little time and is good practice for later. The 8-mark model answer on fiscal policy and HDI shows the shape.
- IB: use two or three of the four questions, anchor at least one in a real example, and make the judgement explicit. More detail is in how I teach the Paper 1 essay, and for data response, the DEED method for Paper 2.
- H2: do all of that, and name the assumption the argument rests on. For example, that firms pass a cost increase on to consumers, or that households spend a transfer rather than save it, then say whether it holds here. SEAB's AO4 asks for exactly this. Higher Nucleus has a full H2 Economics guide, and the 9570 syllabus lists the "management of exchange rates (case of Singapore)" among its content, so Singapore examples are worth having ready: Budget 2026 has plenty.
Students moving between syllabuses carry more across than they think. If you're choosing between them, Higher Nucleus compares H1 and H2 Economics, and I've written about moving from IGCSE to IB.
I teach H2 Economics at Higher Nucleus Learning Studio and IGCSE and IB Economics at KS Academia Prep.
Sources
- SEAB: GCE A-Level H2 Economics 9570 syllabus, 2026 (assessment objectives and scheme of assessment, pp. 5 to 7)
- Cambridge IGCSE Economics 0455 syllabus, 2027 to 2029
- Cambridge IGCSE Economics 0455, 2027 specimen Paper 2 mark scheme
- IB Economics guide, first assessment 2022: external assessment and markbands (pp. 57 to 65)
Paper structures, objectives and markband wording: the SEAB, Cambridge and IB documents listed. The four evaluation questions and the advice by level: my own teaching method.