Most of the Paper 1 scripts I see don't lose marks on theory. They lose them on structure and time: a part (a) that runs long, a part (b) that ends before the evaluation starts, and a real-world example that is mentioned but never used.
This is how I teach the paper. The structure and the markband wording come from the IB's own Economics guide, so you can check every claim yourself.
What Paper 1 actually is
- 1 hour 15 minutes, at both SL and HL.
- Calculators are not permitted in Paper 1, and you get five minutes of reading time before you start.
- You answer one question from a choice of three.
- Each question has two parts: part (a) for 10 marks and part (b) for 15 marks, so 25 marks in total.
- It is worth 30% of the SL grade and 20% of the HL grade. HL questions can include HL extension material; SL questions can't.
If an older revision book tells you to write two essays, it's describing the paper from before the current syllabus (first assessed in 2022). Today it is one question, in two parts.
The detail most students miss: the guide's table of assessment objectives shows that synthesis and evaluation (AO3) are assessed in part (b) only. Evaluation in part (a) earns nothing. Spend those minutes explaining the theory fully instead.
A time split that matches the marks
75 minutes for 25 marks is 3 minutes a mark. Split the paper the same way:
| Step | Marks | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Read all three questions and choose one | - | 5 min |
| Part (a): explain | 10 | 25 min |
| Part (b): the essay | 15 | 40 min |
| Check diagrams, labels and the conclusion | - | 5 min |
Choose the question by its part (b), not its part (a). Part (b) carries 60% of the marks and needs a real-world example you actually know well.
Part (a): explain, don't evaluate
For 9 to 10 marks the guide asks for theory that is "fully explained", terms "used appropriately throughout", and, where relevant, diagrams that are "included and fully explained". So part (a) is a clean definition, one well-labelled diagram, and a chain of reasoning that walks through the diagram step by step. Stop there.
The part (b) skeleton I teach
I teach this in the same order every time: I model a full essay, we build one together, then the student writes one alone. The skeleton is what makes that repeatable.
- Plan (4 min). Underline the command term. If it says "discuss", the guide wants "a considered and balanced review", with conclusions "presented clearly and supported by appropriate evidence". Write one topic sentence for every paragraph below before you write anything else.
- Introduction (2 min). Two sentences: define the key term, then say what you will analyse and evaluate.
- Analysis 1 (8 min). Your strongest argument, with a diagram. Cause, mechanism, effect, linked back to the question.
- Analysis 2 (6 min). A second channel, a different stakeholder, or the real-world example developed in full.
- Counter-argument (8 min). Challenge an assumption: elasticity, time lags, government failure, opportunity cost.
- Evaluation and judgement (8 min). Weigh the two sides and decide.
- Conclusion (2 min). Restate the judgement and what it depends on. No new arguments.
That is 38 minutes, which leaves two minutes of slack inside the 40.
What the 13 to 15 band actually asks for
These are the six descriptors for the top band of part (b), quoted from the guide:
- "The specific demands of the question are understood and addressed."
- "Relevant economic theory is fully explained."
- "Relevant economic terms are used appropriately throughout the response."
- "Where appropriate, relevant diagram(s) are included and fully explained."
- "The response contains evidence of effective and balanced synthesis or evaluation."
- "A relevant real-world example(s) is identified and fully developed to support the argument."
Two things are worth noticing. First, the real-world example is part of the descriptor, not a decoration: in the 7 to 9 band it is only "partly developed", and at 13 to 15 it is "fully developed to support the argument". Second, the step from 10 to 12 up to 13 to 15 is evaluation that is "effective and balanced", not just "mostly balanced".
Evaluation that makes a judgement
Listing advantages and disadvantages isn't evaluation. A judgement is. These openers push students into one:
- "The effectiveness of this policy depends on..." (then name the variable: an elasticity, a time horizon, a magnitude).
- "In the short run... but in the long run..."
- "While the theory suggests..., in practice... means that... is more likely."
- "On balance..., because..."
"In conclusion, subsidies have advantages and disadvantages. They can correct market failure but they also have costs. It depends on the situation."
"How far a vaccination subsidy raises take-up depends on why people under-consume. Where the barrier is price, and demand is relatively price elastic, the subsidy moves consumption towards the socially optimal level. Where the barrier is information, a lower price changes little, so the subsidy works better alongside a public information campaign that tackles the information failure directly."
Where to find the real-world example
For Singapore examples with checked figures, I've mapped Singapore's Budget 2026 to the Economics syllabus. For diagrams, KS Academia Prep's guide to every diagram in IB Economics has how-to-draw steps for each one, and their SL vs HL guide covers Papers 2 and 3 and the IA.
If you'd like your essays marked against these bands, I teach IB Economics at KS Academia Prep, in English and Mandarin.
Sources
- IB Economics guide, first assessment 2022: assessment outlines, external assessment details and markbands (pp. 57 to 65)
Paper structure, weightings and markband wording: IB Economics guide (first assessment 2022). Time split, skeleton and evaluation openers: my own teaching notes.